Chapter 1 of a suspenseful thriller where ordinary people face extraordinary danger and must fight to survive.

A tale about killing and ghostly events that happens on a misty evening in the Florida Keys. This story was heard before on the show back on December 19, 1949.

When Valerie becomes the center of a murder investigation, the protagonists must navigate police scrutiny while racing to the island's boathouse, where the truth about their missing friends may determine whether they become suspects or victims.