Chapter 1 of a suspenseful thriller where ordinary people face extraordinary danger and must fight to survive.

In a Los Angeles neighborhood, two young criminals are stealing purses and assaulting their victims. The announcer delivers an extended thank you speech to everyone who helped make the show possible on its first anniversary before the episode begins. Following the story, the Los Angeles Chief of Police offers praise for the program.

Jerry Browning dresses up as Santa Claus, but so do 5 other guys...one of whom is a pickpocket! A good Christmas show.

"Raymond" presents a story with no given title about the killing of a man who created a medicine to fix people who cannot see colors properly. Though the story has no announced name, people often call it "Elixir Number Four" or "The Color Blind Formula." The tale has a shocking twist at the end that will make you angry! The AFRS program is called "Mystery Playhouse." When the story ends, Peter Lorre shows a preview of "The Whistler" episode called "Death Sees Double." This story has parts like the one listed as number 5585, but it is clearly different.

Lawyer Dave Morton sits alone in his dark office, troubled by the death of a pretty young married woman. He learns that the killer who got away with murder was one of three men who attacked her. Dave becomes obsessed with getting revenge, which puts both his own life and the life of the man he wants to help in serious danger.