An Identical Murder
Jack lives in a dark apartment filled with memories of his identical twin brother Vinnie, who died tragically. Jack wants to start fresh with his new wife Anne, but Vinnie's ghost won't leave them alone. Their friends Harry and a woman who talks to spirits try to help when Jack's voice changes and Vinnie's spirit follows the couple even on their wedding trip. Jack fights against something no one can see, leading to a surprising discovery.
A dim apartment echoes with memories of Jack and his identical twin, Vinnie, whose tragic death still looms over Jack's plans for a new life with Anne. Friends Harry and a woman medium struggle to help Anne when Jack's voice and Vinnie's presence haunt the couple even on their honeymoon. Jack's final struggle against an unseen force leads to a shocking revelation.
Ann Slater knows that both Jack and Vince Benton, identical twins, are in love with her, though neither Ann nor Jack is prepared for Vince's angry reaction when he learns of their engagement. After Vince's death in a mountain climbing accident, Ann feels free to marry Jack—until Vince's ghost appears, intent on breaking up the romance. Realizing the ghost has more of Jack's characteristics than his brother's, Ann begins to worry that she is marrying the wrong man.
CBS Radio Mystery Theater is a radio drama series created by Himan Brown that was broadcast on CBS Radio Network affiliates from 1974 to 1982, and later in the early 2000s was repeated by the NPR satellite feed. In New York City it was not aired by the then all-news WCBS but by its originating station, WOR, which produced and announced it as simply Radio Mystery Theater.
Wikipedia. CC BY-SA 4.0. Updated Jul 20, 2026.
“An Identical Murder.” CBS Radio Mystery Theater. Radio broadcast, February 28, 1975.
45m20s
-:-- savedSaved position
42m50s
-:-- savedSaved position
42m38s
-:-- savedSaved position
46m09s
-:-- savedSaved position
42m38s
-:-- savedSaved position



